New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is facing widespread ridicule after issuing what critics called a vague and meaningless warning ahead of a major snowstorm expected to hit the city this weekend.
Mamdani took to X on Thursday to announce the city’s preparations, writing that New York is forecast to receive “3–16 inches of snow” and that officials are ready.
The post quickly sparked mockery across social media, with users accusing the mayor of offering a forecast so broad that it conveyed virtually no useful information.
“3–16, way to narrow down the forecast,” one user wrote.
Another commenter was harsher, calling the statement “idiotic and moronic” and arguing that a range that wide tells residents nothing about what to expect. Others joked that city officials may have forgotten to add a digit to the lower end of the estimate.
The backlash intensified after forecasters pointed out that the National Weather Service had already placed all five boroughs under a winter storm watch at the time of Mamdani’s post, calling for 6 to 12 inches of snow.
Updated forecasts now predict between 8 and 14 inches could fall across the city.
Critics seized on the discrepancy, accusing the mayor of either misunderstanding the forecast or oversimplifying it to the point of absurdity.
The New York Post reported that the post quickly became a lightning rod as New Yorkers questioned Mamdani’s readiness to handle one of the most basic challenges facing a city mayor.
Snowstorms have long been a political test for New York City leaders, with past mayors suffering lasting damage from perceived mismanagement.
Mayor Bill de Blasio was heavily criticized in 2014 after residents complained that plows and salt trucks were slow to respond during a major storm, particularly in Staten Island.
Former Mayor Michael Bloomberg (D) faced similar backlash after the city struggled to clear streets during the infamous Christmas blizzard of 2010, a storm that paralyzed parts of the city for days.
Decades earlier, then-Mayor John Lindsay (R) was slammed for the city’s sluggish response to the massive 1969 snowstorm, which stranded commuters and shut down large portions of New York, per Silive.com.
Those past failures have made snow response a political minefield, and critics argue Mamdani’s clumsy messaging has already put him on shaky ground. While city officials insist preparations are underway, the mayor’s forecast range has become a symbol for what opponents describe as amateurish leadership.
Supporters say Mamdani was simply acknowledging uncertainty in weather models, but the online reaction suggests patience is thin as the storm approaches.
With heavy snow expected to begin this weekend, New Yorkers will soon find out whether Mamdani’s administration is truly ready — or whether his first major winter test will add him to the long list of mayors remembered for getting snowstorms wrong.
