Best Outcome Possible to ‘Are We Dating the Same Guy?’ Facebook Group

Seventy days in jail. Thirty-six months of supervised probation. Court-ordered intervention programs. Restrictions on his use of dating apps. 

Those are the consequences now facing a West Linn, Oregon, man whose conduct toward women he met online drew a police investigation.

Nicholas Michael Donohue, 47, pleaded guilty in a series of cases that grew out of complaints from women, according to the West Linn Police Department.

The local outlet KOIN carried the department’s account of how the matter unfolded.

That account starts in May 2024. 

Police in the Clackamas County city began examining Donohue’s conduct when two separate items reached investigators: reports of “concerning behavior” on dating apps, and a post in the Facebook group “Are We Dating the Same Guy?”

The department did not stop at those first leads. 

Over the course of its work, it opened four cases against Donohue, “each from a woman who met him on a dating app and reported assaultive and abusive behavior.”

Four cases, then, and one shared starting point: a dating app.

Donohue ultimately admitted guilt in court. 

He pleaded guilty to two counts of coercion, along with “one count of fourth-degree assault-domestic violence and one count of attempted coercion.”

Tallied up, the pleas cover four counts. Two are for coercion, one is for attempted coercion, and one is for assault in the fourth degree with a domestic-violence designation.

The 70-day jail term is only one piece of the sentence. Alongside it, Donohue must serve 36 months of supervised probation.

The court also requires Donohue to take part in intervention programs for batterers and substance abusers.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

One more condition reaches into his online life. Donohue will face “dating app restrictions.”

Dating apps figure at every stage of the case. They are where the first reports surfaced, where each of the four women met Donohue, and the subject of the restrictions in his sentence.

Facebook figures in the timeline as well. A post in the “Are We Dating the Same Guy?” group is one of the two items the department cited when it began investigating.

Details of that post are not publicly available. The Portland “Are We Dating the Same Guy?” group is private, so people outside it cannot read what members post.

The broader network is easier to size up. 

Wikipedia describes “Are We Dating The Same Guy?” as a collection of more than 200 individual Facebook groups. 

The network works through individual groups rather than a single page.

Their purpose is specific. 

A woman posts the dating profile of a man she matched with on a dating network and asks for the opinion of other women, particularly those who may have dated him before.

The groups have attracted critics. 

Some argue the pages unfairly target innocent men who are simply going on dates with multiple women, and that the men get no chance to defend themselves.

Other critics focus on reputation. 

They describe an environment in which “subjective accounts about dating behavior are interpreted as factual assessments and can influence a person’s reputation among large audiences within their locale.”

The two arguments differ in focus. One concerns the men named in posts and their ability to respond. The other concerns how accounts of dating behavior travel among local audiences.

Lawsuits have followed. The groups have been the subject of some legal action tied to those concerns.

The department’s description of the complaints is brief: four women, four cases, and a dating-app meeting in each.

Donohue’s sentence combines jail, probation, intervention programs and limits on dating-app use.

The department’s tally in the Donohue matter reads as follows: four cases, four counts to which he pleaded guilty, and a 70-day jail sentence. 

KOIN’s report cited the department’s description of the four cases and the sentence terms.

The investigation began in May 2024. Reports of the outcome appeared in November 2026.

By Reece Walker

Reece Walker covers news and politics with a focus on exposing public and private policies proposed by governments, unelected globalists, bureaucrats, Big Tech companies, defense departments, and intelligence agencies.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x