Rep. LaMonica McIver (D-NJ) has suffered another significant legal setback after a federal appeals court refused to reconsider a ruling allowing criminal charges against her to move forward following a confrontation with federal immigration officers.
The decision, issued Thursday, November 19, leaves the progressive lawmaker facing prosecution over an incident at an immigration detention facility in Newark, where federal authorities allege she physically interfered with officers attempting to make an arrest.
McIver, who has accused President Donald Trump’s administration of politically motivated prosecution, warned that she could face up to 17 years in prison if convicted.
The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected her request to revisit an August ruling that determined congressional immunity did not protect her from prosecution on at least two of the three charges.
The congresswoman immediately criticized the outcome, arguing that the case threatens the ability of elected representatives to conduct oversight of federal agencies.
“Donald Trump continues to send warning shots to Democrats in Congress and in all levels of power,” McIver declared.
She accused the Justice Department of targeting her for carrying out her responsibilities as a member of Congress.
“Because of a weaponized Department of Justice and because I dared to do my job and conduct oversight of ICE, I am facing 17 years in prison,” she continued.
The legal dispute dates back to May 9, 2025, when McIver joined other Democratic officials during an unannounced visit to Delaney Hall, an immigration detention facility in Newark.
The visit quickly escalated into a confrontation involving lawmakers, federal immigration officers and Newark Mayor Ras Baraka.
Baraka was arrested during the disturbance, prompting a chaotic encounter that ultimately led to criminal charges against McIver.
Federal prosecutors accused the congresswoman of assaulting and obstructing officers during the confrontation.
According to court documents, McIver allegedly slammed her forearm into an officer who was attempting to arrest the mayor.
Prosecutors also claimed she struck another officer with both forearms while attempting to move into a secured portion of the facility.
McIver has disputed the government’s characterization of her actions and maintained that she was performing legitimate congressional oversight.
Her attorneys argued that the Constitution protects lawmakers from prosecution for activities connected to their legislative responsibilities.
However, a divided federal appeals panel rejected that argument concerning two of the charges in August.
Judge Cindy Chung, appointed by former President Joe Biden, joined Trump-appointed Judge Stephanos Bibas in concluding that the alleged physical conduct did not qualify as protected legislative activity.
The majority determined that McIver’s alleged intervention in Baraka’s arrest was not sufficiently connected to any legislative function protected by congressional immunity.
The judges also rejected the argument that allegedly pushing past and striking federal officers could be shielded by the Constitution.
Their reasoning distinguished between lawmakers’ authority to inspect federal facilities and physical actions that prosecutors allege crossed into unlawful interference.
Judge Thomas Ambro disagreed.
In his dissent, Ambro warned that the majority’s interpretation could weaken Congress’ ability to oversee executive branch agencies.
He argued that preventing lawmakers from entering Department of Homeland Security facilities could interfere with legitimate oversight inspections.
The August ruling permitted two charges to proceed while returning the third to a lower court for additional consideration.
Thursday’s decision leaves that outcome unchanged.
For McIver, the setback means her attempt to block prosecution through congressional immunity has failed at the appeals court level, although additional legal options remain available, per Trending Politics.
The congresswoman said she and her attorneys are examining their next steps.
“Now, due to the disappointing decision by the Third Circuit, we are all one step closer to a world in which the President of the United States can try to imprison people simply because he does not like what they stand for,” she warned.
McIver could potentially ask the Supreme Court to review the dispute, although the justices would have to agree to consider the case.
The ruling does not establish that McIver committed the crimes alleged by federal prosecutors.
Instead, it addresses whether congressional immunity prevents the government from pursuing the charges.
The congresswoman remains presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
The case now stands as a closely watched legal confrontation over the limits of congressional oversight and the authority of federal officers during immigration enforcement operations.
With the appeals court declining to reconsider its earlier decision, McIver faces the possibility of a criminal trial as the dispute over her actions at the Newark detention facility continues.
