Attorneys for the City of Charlotte told a judge that “systemwide crime and incidents” made the fatal attack on Iryna Zarutska “reasonably foreseeable.” The same filing disputes that the city caused her death.
The city submitted its motion to dismiss Monday in Mecklenburg County Superior Court.
The document seeks to end the wrongful death lawsuit that Zarutska’s family brought over her killing aboard a light rail train in August 2025.
It is Charlotte’s first public response to the case, The Charlotte Observer reported.
Zarutska, a 23-year-old refugee from Ukraine, died after a stabbing on the train. Prosecutors charged DeCarlos Brown Jr. Police arrested him shortly afterward, and he remains in custody.
Zarutska’s uncle, Frank Scott Haskell, sued the city and its transit security contractor, Professional Security Services, known as PSS, a year after her death.
His complaint blames “systemic failures” for the tragedy.
City attorneys addressed the killing directly in their motion.
They wrote that the city “recognizes the tragic and devastating death of Iryna Zarutska as the result of an intentional criminal attack by DeCarlos Brown Jr” and then stated their position on the claims against Charlotte.
Those attorneys deny that Charlotte “ignored passenger safety or that its conduct legally caused that attack.”
They also dispute that thin security staffing or a lack of fare enforcement led to her death.
The two sides met for mediation earlier this month. According to the Observer, that session produced no progress.
Haskell’s complaint rests on a series of specific claims.
It says the city failed to “protect lawful passengers from known and foreseeable dangers” and that his niece’s death could have been prevented.
Staffing numbers anchor part of the suit.
The complaint says Charlotte funded 219 security personnel for fiscal years 2025 and 2026. It claims only 183 staff members worked the system when Zarutska died.
The armed-guard figures run lower still. According to the filing, the budget called for 39 armed guards, yet only 11 were on staff at the time.
The lawsuit also targets fare enforcement. It notes that the light rail system has no turnstiles at any stop, and it claims Brown boarded without paying a fare.
Brown, a homeless man, had previously told police he had schizophrenia, according to the filing. Haskell contends the open fare system allowed him to board the train and carry out the attack.
The complaint further accuses the city of instructing light rail conductors not to confront passengers who skip fares.
It lists four other homicides and assaults that occurred near Blue Line stops in recent years.
Surveillance video from the night of the attack shows what happened in the car.
The footage appeared to show Brown watching Zarutska for some time while she sat in the row directly in front of him. He then appeared to pull a blade from his pocket.
Brown stood and swung the knife at Zarutska as she sat looking at her phone. He loomed over her as he did so.
The video then shows Zarutska curled up with her knees against her chest and her hands over her mouth, looking up at him. About 15 seconds later, she fell to the floor.
Brown left a trail of blood as he stepped off the train. Other passengers did not appear to realize a killing had just taken place around them.
Footage of the attack spread widely last year and drew national attention. The judge in Mecklenburg County has not yet ruled on the city’s motion.
