Clarence Thomas Goes Public

An ophthalmologist in California challenged a state rule that dictates part of what she must say when she teaches fellow physicians. On Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court turned away her appeal.

Justice Clarence Thomas wrote a dissent from that decision, and Justice Samuel Alito joined him.

Dr. Azadeh Khatibi brought the case. She teaches courses that physicians must complete to maintain their medical licenses, and California sets rules for what those courses contain.

One of those rules concerns implicit bias. State law directs continuing medical education courses involving direct patient care to include a discussion of implicit bias in medical treatment. 

Instructors must address several issues, among them how unconscious attitudes can affect medical decisions.

Khatibi objected on First Amendment grounds. In her view, the mandate compels her to communicate the state’s preferred viewpoint, one she says she does not share.

California adopted the requirement as part of an effort to address alleged disparities in healthcare outcomes among racial and demographic groups. 

Supporters of the rule argue that implicit bias can influence treatment even when healthcare professionals have no conscious intent to treat patients differently.

Khatibi’s attorneys argued the state had other tools available. 

California could provide its own implicit-bias training, they said, or require doctors to receive separate instruction, all without making private educators personally deliver the message.

The courts below did not agree. 

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals concluded that California may impose content requirements on these courses, reasoning that they serve a professional licensing function the state regulates. 

Khatibi then took her case to the nation’s highest court.

The justices denied her petition without giving a reason, which is the customary practice when the court declines to hear a case.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Thomas supplied his own reasoning in writing. 

He argued that the dispute raises important constitutional questions about how far government may go in dictating what private speakers must say.

His opinion began with a rule for situations like this one. 

“When, as here, the government does not issue its own messages but instead requires private speakers to communicate the government’s viewpoint, the First Amendment applies,” Thomas wrote.

He continued with a direct challenge to the state’s position. 

“A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny. We should not permit the government-speech doctrine to be wielded as ‘a cover for censorship’ or a cloak for compelled speech,” he added.

Thomas also pointed to the broader principle. 

“The First Amendment generally prohibits the government from telling people what they must say,” he wrote.

His dissent looked past the medical field as well. 

He wrote that allowing governments to require private instructors to communicate government-selected ideas could reach well beyond medicine. 

“If California can force a doctor to convey the State’s preferred message in a continuing medical education course, there is little reason why it could not force other professionals to do the same,” Thomas wrote.

According to the opinion, the constitutional problem becomes especially serious when a government requires a private speaker to present contested ideas, as opposed to simply disclosing factual information. 

Thomas also said a state cannot escape First Amendment scrutiny merely because the compelled speech takes place in a professional or educational setting.

He summed up that point in one sentence. “Private citizens do not become government mouthpieces simply because they teach a state-mandated course,” Thomas wrote.

The case sits on a line the justices have drawn before, between government regulation of professional conduct and government-compelled speech.

In 2018, in National Institute of Family and Life Advocates v. Becerra, the court struck down portions of a California law that required pregnancy centers to provide certain government-mandated notices.

In that decision, the court rejected the idea that “professional speech” is a separate category entitled to reduced First Amendment protection. 

Thomas cited those principles as he argued that Khatibi’s challenge deserved the court’s review.

By Reece Walker

Reece Walker covers news and politics with a focus on exposing public and private policies proposed by governments, unelected globalists, bureaucrats, Big Tech companies, defense departments, and intelligence agencies.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x