A deadly semi-truck crash in Washington state this week has intensified scrutiny of the state’s sanctuary policies after authorities reportedly released the driver despite an active ICE detainer.
The collision killed 29‑year-old Robert B. Pearson, raising questions about whether state rules contributed to the fatal crash.
Kamalpreet Singh, 25, an Indian national and California resident, was driving a semi‑truck that struck a stopped Mazda on Thursday morning. Pearson was pronounced dead at the scene.
Federal authorities had requested local law enforcement hold Singh for potential deportation, but state officials released him instead of honoring the ICE detainer, according to The Daily Caller.
ICE detainers allow local authorities to hold foreign nationals for up to 48 hours beyond scheduled release, giving federal officers time to assume custody.
Washington’s sanctuary statutes, codified under RCW 10.93.160, prohibit detaining individuals solely on federal requests without a judicial warrant. Critics argue this legal framework created a public safety gap in this case.
Singh holds a California commercial driver’s license (CDL) and was released from King County Jail on a $100,000 bond, according to Fox News.
Federal records indicate he illegally entered the U.S. in 2023 and was released into the interior. Authorities confirmed he is not connected to other fatal crashes involving Indian nationals sharing his surname in Florida and California.
The crash has renewed focus on CDL standards nationwide.
This year, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) issued an emergency interim rule tightening requirements for non‑domiciled CDL holders after multiple fatal crashes involving out-of-state drivers.
FMCSA reported at least five deadly crashes so far this year involved non-domiciled CDL holders, highlighting risks tied to lax licensing and state compliance.
A federal appeals court has since stayed the rule pending review, allowing some states to continue issuing licenses under pre-rule standards.
State officials defend Washington’s sanctuary policy as a tool to maintain community trust and prioritize local law enforcement resources over federal immigration enforcement.
According to OPB, county sheriffs say they focus on criminal investigations within their jurisdictions, reflecting how sanctuary laws are applied locally.
Supporters maintain that local agencies cannot be forced to act as federal immigration officers without jeopardizing trust in immigrant communities.
Critics contend Singh’s release illustrates the deadly consequences of combining sanctuary protections with lenient CDL issuance, arguing regulatory gaps directly enabled a preventable fatality.
Advocates counter that immigration enforcement remains a federal responsibility and local authorities must operate within legal limits while safeguarding communities.
The Department of Transportation has emphasized stricter enforcement of CDL standards, warning that federal highway funding could be withheld from states that fail to comply with national safety rules.
DOT Secretary Sean Duffy said commercial drivers must be legally authorized, fully trained, and proficient in English to safely operate 80,000‑pound vehicles.
“Every American family deserves assurance that dangerous drivers aren’t on the road,” Duffy said.
As investigations continue, the crash underscores the tension between state sanctuary policies, federal mandates, and public safety.
Lawmakers and regulators are expected to debate reforms addressing both immigration enforcement and commercial driver oversight, highlighting the real-world consequences of regulatory gaps on U.S. highways.
