Video footage places Stefanie Fair at a Chill-N ice cream store in Brentwood, Tennessee, during the hour before troopers arrested her on a DUI charge. WSMV 4 Investigates obtained the recording of her visit.
Tennessee will now pay her $70,000 over that arrest.
A spokesperson for the state attorney general told the outlet that the State Board of Claims approved the settlement, and the payout is expected within the next few weeks.
Fair performed in Wild Orchid, a popular girl group. She formed it in the early 90s with Fergie and Renee Sands.
The Tennessee Highway Patrol arrested Fair in June 2024 while she was driving in Nashville. WSMV 4 Investigates later reported on the details of the stop.
Trooper Keith Velez said he pulled Fair over because she failed to pull over. During a field sobriety test, he claimed, he could smell alcohol on her breath.
Velez addressed that smell directly with the outlet. “There’s a very distinct odor of alcohol that comes from either the person or inside the vehicle,” Velez told the outlet.
Fair remembered the exact moment her stomach dropped. “When he started asking me about drinking, I instantly got this feeling in my stomach – this is bad,” Fair told the outlet.
Troopers charged her with driving under the influence.
Fair rejected the claim about the smell outright. “When he said he could smell it, I knew it was corrupt. This is completely wrong,” she told the outlet.
Bloodwork answered the question two months later. The results came back completely clean, the outlet reported, and they confirmed Fair was sober while she drove.
Her husband, Ron Fair, said the ordeal did not end with the lab results.
According to him, she was “extorted” for her famous reputation after her name and mugshot were used “inaccurately.”
Ron Fair and attorney Benjamin K. Raybin told the outlet that the couple paid a $7,500 fee to have her mugshot removed from Scoop Nashville, a popular social media gossip site.
Raybin, who represents Fair, offered his view on why the state agreed to pay.
“I think that the state has recognized that a lot of these arrests are just completely legally unsupportable and that if they went to a jury trial, a jury would find against them,” Raybin told the outlet.
The Daily Mail contacted Raybin for comment on Fair’s behalf. It also reached out to the attorneys representing Velez.
The timeline now spans more than a year.
Troopers arrested Fair in June 2024, her bloodwork returned two months later, and the State Board of Claims has since approved the $70,000 payment.
Fair is the second sober driver to file a federal lawsuit against Tennessee troopers, according to the WSMV 4 “Sobering Problem” investigation.
That investigation found troopers made up to nine DUI arrests against sober drivers.
Thomas Manis, a Monroe County driver, received the first settlement. The state paid him $75,000 in September, the outlet reported, over a wrongful charge from 2023.
Manis’s lawsuit complaint states that a Tennessee Highway Patrol trooper arrested him after suspecting he had smoked marijuana while driving.
The complaint says he passed the field sobriety test.
The outlet confirmed that Manis’s bloodwork later came back clean, with no drugs or alcohol in his system. The DUI charges against him were dropped.
Two payouts now stand on the record: $75,000 to Manis and $70,000 to Fair. Both drivers were arrested by Tennessee Highway Patrol troopers.
The Daily Mail also contacted the Tennessee Highway Patrol and the state Board of Claims office for comment.
